If your best plumber, HVAC tech, or electrician is getting recruited by a larger operation, one of the first questions they’ll ask the recruiter is: “Do you offer a 401k?” If the answer is yes and yours is no — that conversation just got a lot harder for you.
A 401k retirement plan used to be something only large companies offered. That’s no longer true. Small trade companies in Utah can set up quality 401k plans that compete with what the big shops offer — and it’s easier than most owners think.
A small trade company can set up a 401k plan for as little as $0–$500 in setup costs through a PEO. Employer match contributions are optional but powerful as a retention tool. The plan is fully tax-advantaged for both you and your employees.
Here’s the thing about skilled tradespeople: they’re thinking about their future. An HVAC tech at 35 who’s been doing this work for 10 years is starting to wonder what happens when they can’t do the physical work anymore. When a competitor offers a 401k with employer match and you don’t — you’re telling them “we haven’t thought about your future.”
A 401k does three things for your business:
A 401k is a qualified retirement savings plan where employees contribute pre-tax dollars from their paycheck. As the employer, you can optionally add matching contributions.
The basic structure for a trade company:
The employer match is where you create the real retention power. Common matching structures:
| Match Structure | Annual Cost (10 employees @ $50K avg) | Retention Impact |
|---|---|---|
| No match — access only | $0 | Low — better than nothing |
| 25% match up to 4% of salary | ~$5,000/year | Moderate |
| 50% match up to 6% of salary | ~$15,000/year | Strong |
| 100% match up to 3% of salary | ~$15,000/year | Very strong — “we match dollar for dollar” |
Most small trade companies start with a 50% match up to 6% — it’s a compelling benefit to advertise and the annual cost is manageable. “We match 50 cents on every dollar you save, up to 6% of your salary” is something your techs will actually understand and value.
As a small business owner, a 401k is one of the most powerful tax tools available to you. In 2025, you can contribute:
For a successful trade company owner, deferring $69,000/year from taxable income while building retirement wealth is a significant financial benefit on top of the retention impact.
Setting up a 401k as a standalone small business involves plan documents, a plan administrator, investment selection, annual compliance filings (Form 5500), and discrimination testing. It’s manageable but has meaningful administrative overhead.
Through a PEO like American Benefits Company, your trade company joins a multiple-employer retirement plan — which means the administrative complexity is handled by the PEO, not you. You choose your match rate, employees enroll, and contributions are automatically processed through payroll. The PEO handles the compliance filings and plan administration.
Free advisory service for Utah trade companies — we’ll show you exactly what it would cost.
Once you have it, put it to work. In every job posting: “We offer health insurance, dental, vision, and 401k with employer match.” That sentence puts you in a completely different tier from the dozens of trade companies that offer none of those things.
When your crew refers friends — and they will when they’re happy — the benefits package is often the first thing they mention. “The boss offers 401k and health insurance” is word-of-mouth recruiting that costs you nothing extra.
Free advisory service for Utah trade companies. No cost, no pressure.
Get Free Audit →